2023 hasn't been the best year for Marvel Studios. While "Guardians 3" and season two of "Loki" did well overall, "Quantumania" got a mixed response and "Secret Invasion" was a new low. Though it's a bit of a tennis match between the good and bad products, it's clear they're not the unstoppable juggernaut they once were and it appears with multiple projects being delayed that they're undergoing an overhaul which will hopefully rebuild confidence in the brand. With all these troubles, it's easy to understand why people are writing off "The Marvels", the sequel to 2019's "Captain Marvel" which sees Carol Danvers teaming up with Monica Rambeau and Kamala Khan/Ms. Marvel, with Brie Larson, Teyonah Parris, and Iman Vellani reprising their respective roles. While the overall response is mixed but more positive than "Quantumania", the box office hasn't been pretty and seen by some to be the deathblow to Marvel. But does "The Marvels" warrant such treatment? Is there anything of value to be found here? While I think there is, there are problems.
Right off the bat, the best thing about this movie is the chemistry between the three leads. Particularly during a training montage, you can tell the actresses were having a lot of fun on set. Their individual powers also play well off each other, making for some entertaining action scenes. I also like how the theme of hero worship was dealt with on different levels. While Monica looked up to Carol as a family member and eventually became disenchanted leading to a reconciliation., Kamala loves Captain Marvel in a celebrity sense (and her fangirl reactions are hilarious) and is getting to know her past a surface level. I'm just thankful on the latter that they avoid a whole "never meet your heroes" third act break-up.
On the flipside though, I didn't care for Zawe Ashton as the main villain, Dar-Benn. She's about as engaging as her fellow accuser, i.e. Lee Pace's Ronan in "Guardians 1", mixed with the scene chewing of Elizabeth Banks' Rita Repulsa.
I'm a bit mixed on the story.
They said going in they were going for a wacky tone, and along with standard Marvel comedy, they definitely weren't overselling. But it's not as bad as you'd think. It's the kind of wacky where you just have to roll with the punches and embrace how insane something is, whether it be a planet where the inhabitants communicate only in song or a horde of monster kittens swallowing people to save their lives (which is cute and terrifying).
On the bad side though, it does feel like there were portions cut from the film in order to keep it under two hours (which based on "Suicide Squad" and Joss-tice League is never a good sign). The main issue I found is that they kind of breeze through Carol's actions between her solo film and "Endgame" and doesn't delve deep enough into how it affected her.
The Marvels is also another victim of what I'm calling the "Disney+ crutch", where the series on the service are essential to understand the movie. While not as pivotal to the plot like "Multiverse of Madness", watching "WandaVision" and "Ms. Marvel" help add to the context of references made to them in the film. Again, not everyone streams, so you're leaving part of the audience out of the know. Like, it's fine to reference to other stories, but it has to be subtle. Marvel's done it between the films in the past; Falcon recruited Ant-Man in "Civil War" based a past interaction, but they didn't take you out of the main story to go into detail about their fight in the first Ant-Man movie. Please Marvel, when "Captain America 4" comes out, just show Sam established as the new Cap and get to the story at hand. And on a related note, one plot point in this movie also makes "Secret Invasion" even worse and shows that whole story was entirely avoidable.
Overall, The Marvels isn't the worst. I'd say it's just above "Iron Man 2" and "Thor: The Dark World". It's still entertaining with our lead characters and a unique kind of craziness. There are definitely issues present, but there's still fun to be had as well.