Movie Review: Superman - Old Fashioned Hero For Troubled Times

 

My first review on this blog was for "Man of Steel", which kicked off the DC Extended Universe. Now here we are again with a Superman reboot acting as the first film of a new live action DC Universe. If we can surmise how a shared universe will do based on how its first film is received, I believe the new Superman film will take the DCU to greater heights compared to what came before.

For better or worse, what Richard Donner and Christopher Reeve brought to the first cinematic version of Superman became the archetype for the character on film. So much so that filmmakers after the Reeve films had a hard time cracking how to bring Superman to the modern age of superhero movies. Bryan Singer stayed too close to the Donner aesthetic for comfort with "Superman Returns" while Zack Snyder's version strayed too far from it, both failing to achieve mass appeal to movie goers. But now James Gunn has succeeded in showcasing classic Superman sensibilities while connecting to today's audience. And as much as WB tried to make John Williams' classic score work for Cavill's Superman (who already had his own theme from Hans Zimmer), it fits so much better here and will have you humming along once it hits.
While I appreciate Snyder's grounded "first contact" take, Gunn made the right call diving into a universe unafraid of embracing its comic book roots with Superman and other heroes firmly established, allowing us to jump right into the story. It's a very timely one at that as one can draw parallels to current events from military conflicts to political figures; it really drives in the hope Superman is meant to inspire in others in story and in real life. But there's plenty of fantasy and action to escape into as well, with plenty of ideas keen eyed comic fans will be able to pinpoint their inspiration.

David Corenswet delivers one of the most down-to-Earth Supermen of recent memory; Tyler Hoechlin also fits that bill, though his Superman was at a different stage of life by comparison. Corenswet captures what I believe James Gunn set out with this new version of the character, that despite all his power, Superman is at his core just a guy trying to do the right thing. They also make it clear Clark really is quite nerdy, and I think it's quite evident in the costume. It makes for great chemistry with Rachel Brosnahan's Lois Lane as their ideologies clash. He's an idealist while she's a realist as they help each other see the wider picture of a situation.

Portrayed as an egotist with no regard for any life but his own, Nicholas Hoult makes the perfect antagonist to Corenswet's Superman as he takes on the role of Lex Luthor. Along with seeing direct inspiration from Grant Morrison's depictions of Lex in works like "All Star Superman" and their New 52 Action Comics run, there's undeniable allusions to Donald Trump and Elon Musk.

Saving the day along with Superman is the (name still pending) Justice Gang, made up of Green Lantern Guy Gardner (Nathan Fillion), Mr. Terrific (Edi Gathegi), and Hawkgirl (Isabela Merced). Gardner is brash and loves the limelight while Terrific is serious and calculating. Hawkgirl makes a good middle ground but she doesn't get as much time to shine compared to her teammates (which I feel is a wider problem with some of the supporting cast, including the Daily Planet staff).

And of course, there's everyone's favorite scene stealer, Krypto the Superdog! Covered in fur and wrapped in a red cape, Krypto is the definition of a "chaotic good boy". He may have powers but he's still a hyper dog that will probably make his inclusion worth the price of admission for dog owners and animal lovers everywhere.

All that said, I do have a couple minor gripes:
* Ultraman's identity is easy to figure out, though you may be wondering the specifics until the reveal. He does have an interesting relationship with Lex that makes me think of Stryker and Barakapool done right.

* The change in Superman's Kryptonian parents' intentions for their son kind of rubs me the wrong way, though I understand the intent for his character arc. Although, Gunn may have done an unintentional retread of "He may have been your father, but he wasn't your daddy".

Every few years, I think there's a superhero movie that comes around which reinvigorates the genre. James Gunn's "Superman" has arrived to shake off the fatigue audiences have been feeling the last few years and at a time a hero is sorely needed to make us believe in good. I don't usually make hyperbole comments like some critics do, but this is the must-see film of the year.